top of page

 PIRATE RADIO

The Underground Side of Radio

INTRODUCTION

Pirate radio is a form of the First Amendment. But is it possible for individuals to take the freedom of speech to the point that it challenges the well-being of the public? From the Federal Communications Commission to the culture, the unlicensed, underground world of pirate radio is a warfare through radio wavelengths. Becky Mehorter, Giulia Villanueva, and Jeb Biggart dive into the risks and rewards of pirate radio in the United States.

FCC HISTORY AND REGULATION

WRITTEN BY BECKY MEHORTER

PIRATE RADIO AND THE FCC HITORY

Pirate radio in the United States is defined as unlicensed broadcasting on any radio channel that is licensed to a government, public or commercial entities by the Federal Communications Commission, also known as the FCC.

 

While pirate radio is an illegal activity worldwide, the definition of what is considered piracy varies vastly depending on the regulations of the country from which the programming is broadcasted.

 

Pirates in the United States violate rules set by the FCC, which is an independent U.S. government agency that calls itself “the federal agency responsible for implementing and enforcing America’s communications law and regulations.” The committee is the successor to the Federal Radio Commission, which focused solely on radio airwaves, but it now includes most manners of communication. It is responsible for domestic and international communications over the spectrum, including radio, cable and television.

 

Howard Leib, an entertainment lawyer and law professor at Cornell and Syracuse universities, explained what the FCC governs.

 

“The FCC regulates for the U.S., different agencies do it in other countries, what parts of the spectrum are used by different parts of the industrial and, for purposes of radio and television, regulates who is allowed to broadcast on different frequencies,” Leib said.

 

As per the FCC in Title 47, Part 15 of the Code of Federal Regulations and Congress in Section 301 of the Communications Act of 1934, the FCC requires an FCC-issued license for anyone to “use or operate any apparatus for the transmission of energy or communications or signals by radio,” with few exceptions.

 

Before the FCC or any other communication-regulator entity existed in the United States, there were no rules about using radio waves.

 

“Going back over a hundred years, to 1912, what we now think of radio was kind of the wild, wild West,” Leib said. “If you had enough money to buy a transmitter and antenna, you could go on the air.”

 

Radio regulation in the United States began in 1912 when the Office of Commerce and Labor released “Instructions for Radio Communication,” the first law of airwaves. The document contains mostly instructions for ships and their rules on frequencies, but it also contains the first of the United States’s regulations on wavelength restrictions, costs of stations and how stations were to be organized by the federal government.

 

The instructions were released following two events. After the sinking of the Titanic, there was a push to pass legislation to improve radio communication. Then when people realized they could make money off of "wireless telegraph," Leib said, radio enthusiasts also peitioned Congress to pass airwave laws. But this request was less in the spirit of organization and for more capitalistic and technical reasons, Leib said.

 

“If you put radio stations or television stations too close together on frequencies, all you get is interference," he said. "And so these very early broadcasters wanted frequencies that they could broadcast on that other people in their areas wouldn’t be broadcasting on so that they could have an audience and monetize these entities.”

 

Article 8 of the “Instructions for Radio Communication” states, “The working of the wireless telegraph [radio] stations shall be organized as far as possible in such manner as not to disturb the service of other wireless stations.” Assigning stations through licenses would prevent interference so radio broadcasters could guarantee to advertisers that listeners could hear advertisments. Licenses would also ensure that something like the tragedy of the Titanic, which was in part caused by faulty radio communications. 

 

The start of the regulations had a trade-off for broadcasters who wanted to profit from their radio stations.

 

“What happened back in near early part of the 1900s, is a deal was made,” Leib said. “And that deal was in essence: ‘We, the federal government will regulate the electronic spectrum. You, broadcasters, will recognize that you do not own the spectrum, that it is owned by the public. And you will also agree to broadcast in the public interest.’”

 

Leib said that, among other obligations, stations had to air public affairs and community-interest programming, to let opposing political sides both have airtime and to let politicians running for office buy advertising time at low rates, so the frequencies would benefit the public.

 

These requirements were not agreeable with all people who had an interest in producing radio content, so some pirates decided to work outside of the federal regulations in order to avoid required programming.

 

Even though many of the original regulations have changed due to advancements in technology, as well as increased demand in channels of communication, the FCC continues to govern to avoid interference and other inherent problems that stem from unlicensed radio.

 

Daniel Roberts, director and founder of Pirate Cat Radio, said many pirates don’t initially think about all of the ways they might be disturbing people when they first set up transmitters.

 

New York State Percentage of FCC Enforce

“There are a lot of potential issues you can cause by broadcasting and turning on the transmitter if you don’t know what you’re doing,” Roberts said. “While it’s really easy to acquire the equipment and put it on the air, it takes a whole other skill to be able to understand … what things are you possibly interfering with, what amount of power are you putting out in a residential area that might cut out people’s cell phone service, for example.”

 

Besides issues the public might face due to pirate radio, there are consequences for the pirates themselves. The FCC writes on its website, “Parties found operating radio stations without FCC authorization will be subject to a variety of enforcement actions including seizure of equipment, imposition of monetary forfeitures, ineligibility to hold any FCC license, and criminal penalties.”

​

FCC Enforcement Actions per Person by St

The commission reported taking official enforcement actions in 2,086 cases from January 1, 2003, to August 26, 2018, with almost a quarter of the actions occurring in New York State. Click here to read more on the culture of pirate radio in New York.

​

The FCC said fines in New York State have been at most $20,000, but, from the 516 state cases, fines average to about $10,210. Overall, New York State has fined radio pirates $418,600 from January 2003 to August 2018.​

 

 

The current administration is attempting to raise both the number of fines given and the dollar amount of fines in the new PIRATE Act. Read more about the act here.

 

Yet pirate radio continues despite the consequences as pirates do not want to be licensed. Licensed radio stations are required to adhere to strict technical regulations, to pay both regulatory and processing fees and to abide by the approved censors.

 

Not all radio producers have the money or desire to follow the FCC’s statutes, so they turn to pirate radio, even with the duty to think about how they will affect the surrounding community and the constant fear of being caught by the FCC.​​

​

“A radio station to run … is a huge responsibility,” Roberts said. “It’s not something you can really kind of, take lightly, while as the slogan at the time was ‘Pirate Cat Radio: We can say f---.’”

This graphic depicts the states with the highest number of cases per person in the United States. New York has the most cases overall in the country, and it has the second most in cases per person.

two.png

THE CULTURE OF PIRATE RADIO

WRITTEN BY JEB BIGGART

Culture of Pirate Radio

Finding a Voice for the Less Mainstream Demographic

 

The New York City borough of Brooklyn stretches 71 square miles, housing over 2 million residents from varying cultures and ethnicities. Among those 2 million citizens, nearly 46 percent speak a language other than English, according to a 2017 census. Such a staggering number of cultures and languages translates to a vast difference in music taste among the population, yet the radio remains a predominantly English-speaking media outlet. Within those Brooklyn streets lie fifty-five separate pirate radio stations that risk high fines from the FCC to spread their music and language via radio wavelengths on unlicensed equipment.

 

 

Fines for using an unlicensed radio broadcast can reach up to $144,000, but when the average Brooklyn resident makes just over $46,000 in yearly income, one has to question why an individual would put so much at risk for a pirate radio station?

 

Pirate radio DJ Daniel Roberts has been in the unlicensed broadcast scene since he was just 15 years old. Since then, the 37-year-old has watched pirate radio evolve into a cultural outlet for individuals to broadcast their heritage through music and talk shows. The risk of the FCC doesn’t impact Roberts’ choice to continue his illegal broadcasts.

“A lot of the influence comes from different things and different cultures,” Roberts said. “It helps to kind of spread knowledge and information, and is it worth the risk? Sure, why not? Until we get caught. Then maybe I’ll have a different opinion.”

 

Unlike regular radio broadcasts restricted by FCC restrictions, pirate radio broadcasts give the operator free reign of their freedom of speech. The United States practices regulation of the radio spectrum in favor of the larger corporations. Many pirate radio stations consider their work to be a challenge against that authority. Roberts displayed this anarchist behavior in the simplest form with his broadcast slogan; “Pirate Cat Radio: We can say f---.”

 

The Spread of Jewish Pirate Radio

 

Among the fifty-five known pirate radio stations in the Brooklyn area, four broadcast Jewish music in an effort to celebrate the religion and its presence in New York City. In 2014, one of those four stations, known as J-Root, was shut down for failing to comply with FCC regulations. Thousands had previously tuned into the 24-hour radio broadcast for a variance of Jewish programming for all ages.

 

The station has since pivoted toward online broadcasts where the FCC has no jurisdiction of its broadcast.

 

Without a mainstream outlet to broadcast their culture through the radio waves, Jewish individuals relied on the illegal radio broadcasts to air a pillar of their religion. Orthodox Jewish lawyer Martin Berger said he believes that music is a crucial component in his religion.

 

“It’s huge," Berger said. "It’s very very big. During Hanukkah, which we’re in right now, there’s concerts every night, everywhere. People want to be happy and joyous with the big performers. All the concerts are sold out. You can’t even get tickets. Everybody is singing everywhere.”

 

The music scene within the Jewish religion has been steadily growing, according to Berger, yet many of the most popular Jewish radio stations remain on unlicensed radio broadcasts.

 

“In the 1960s and 70s, there maybe were four or five very popular Jewish musicians,” Berger said. “These days, there are probably 60 or 70 to 100 who are all over making albums all the time. The Jewish music industry has exploded over the past 15 to 20 years.”

 

Representation of the Audience

 

Jewish music isn’t the only demographic on pirate radio. Among many Judaic stations, therein lies Haitian, Jamaican, Caribbean and countless other cultures that use unlicensed broadcasts to convey their musical heritage.

 

New York City most likely has more illegally broadcasted FM radio stations than legal ones. The mainstream radio broadcasts do little to represent their listener’s culture. Instead, they air songs from the Billboard charts and stick to musical and advertising decisions that will produce the most revenue. Without pirate radio, many cultures that make up New York City’s melting pot would go underrepresented within radio media.

 

Stations broadcasting out of Brooklyn stem further than just outlets for religion or music. Brooklyn station Triple 9HD boasts a lineup of lawyers and talk-show hosts that provide legal advice for immigrants in the area during the time the station isn't playing Spanish music. Wei-Vybz station promotes feminism and inclusivity, while the Radio Comedy station gives comedians who don't speak English an outlet for their work.

 

The Minority Media Communications Council has stated its distaste for pirate radio, stating that the unlicensed broadcasts put minorities at a disadvantage. However, the current environment of radio broadcast leaves little room for the less-represented audiences of the country.

 

Unlicensed broadcasts can prove to be a problem for legal broadcasters, violate FCC regulations and advertise unapproved products. However, the diverse ethnic outlet it has become makes it a crucial component for individuals from varying heritages.

THE FCC PERSPECTIVE

WRITTEN BY GIULIA VILLANUEVA LOPEZ

internet and pirate radio

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is an independent U.S. government agency that is in charge of stopping any station from illegally broadcasting without a license.

 

​

David Donovan, former legal counsel to an FCC Commissioner and current president of the New York State Broadcasting Association (NYSBA), said the FCC got approval from the House Energy and Commerce Committee on passing a bill called the PIRATE Act. This will increase FCC’s fines and enforcement on pirate radio stations.

 

But in order for the bill to officially take effect, the U.S. Senate has to also approve by the end of the year or else the FCC will have to start over in re-submitting the same bill.

 

“I think the more and more people realize the immediate harm they [radio pirates] are causing to the public, then the government will really begin to move and increase its enforcement efforts,” Donovan said.

​

The PIRATE Act

According to a House of Representatives report, Donovan gave a testimony on March 22, 2018, to the Subcommittee on Communications and Technology, House Energy and Commerce Committee and the House of Representatives. The testimony helped introduce the bill, H.R. 5709, also known as the PIRATE Act, which was then amended on July 12, 2018.

 

The bill’s requirements are to give the FCC “additional authority to issue fines on any person who willfully and knowingly broadcasts radio transmissions over AM or FM frequencies without a license form.”

 

The bill also states it will raise the fine for rule violations to “$100,000 dollars per day per violation, up to a maximum of $2,000,000 dollars.”
 

Another requirement is the FCC doing “annual sweeps not less than once each year … additional monitoring ... Within six months after conducting the enforcement sweeps.”

 

Problems with Pirate Radio

 

Pirate Act

According to Donovan, radio pirates cause four major harms. The first harm is that pirate radio can interfere with existing radio stations licensed by the FCC. Radio pirates interrupt the stations’ messages, including the ones from the national Emergency Alert System.

 

Donovan said the second harm is when pirate radio stations disrupt airport communication.


“The FCC has tried to stop these, but the problem that you have is that the interference occurs while a plane is landing or at an airport," Donovan said. "The remedy is [ex] post facto. In other words, interference occurs, and then you have to go to try to track down the pirate, and that can be long and difficult.”

 

The third issue is that there are hundreds of pirate radio transmitters operating throughout New York City, Miami and other major cities. All transmitters use electromagnetic energy, and pirate radio transmitters add to the amount of radiation people are exposed to. The extensive number of unlicensed transmitters causes problems with the regulated FCC radio frequency radiation (RFR) standards, which include having six feet fences and towers around broadcasting stations.

The final harm radio pirates cause is driving minority ownership in radio out of business. Donovan explained minority-owned stations live by FCC rules, but an illegal pirate interrupts their messages. The Minority Media Communications Council and National Association Black on Black Broadcasters said to stop radio pirates because they exploit communities away.

 

Donovan said he thinks the current Federal Communications Act isn’t effective because it was designed back in the 30s to deal with illegal broadcasters. The difference between then and now, he said, is that broadcasters in the past were more compliant with the FCC than pirates now.

 

“If you got a letter from the FCC, ‘Hey, don’t do this anymore,’ you stopped doing it," Donovan said. "You now have in the last 10 or 20 years developed an entire class of illegal operators that literally don’t care about the law."

 

Donovan said he hopes the PIRATE Act will be approved because it will require the FCC to conduct "sweeps" in the major markets where there are a significant number of pirate radio populations.

 

 

 

How the FCC tracks Radio Pirates

 

Donovan gave a step-by-step account of how the FCC conducts its search for pirate radio stations. The Bureau of Enforcement manages legal actions against pirates.

 

First, the agents turn on an FM radio and spin the dial. They know which stations are licensed, and if they hear a station operating on a frequency that is not in the FCC licensing database, they have a good idea that, that station is operating without a license.

 

The agents then go out and get a spectrum analyzer and a truck. Next, they drive around to various locations and use the analyzer to track down where the illegal transmitter is.

 

And finally, they take measurements on the frequency, location, power and from that, they can decide if the station is following FCC rules.

 

Pirate Radio and The Internet

 

The internet is an online platform where content is not censored or regulated by the FCC. So why do radio pirates not use this outlet?

​

Donovan said it’s because radio pirates see there is a market where people listening to the radio everywhere, especially in cars.

 

But the main reason they decide to broadcast illegally has to do with money.
 

“The cost of buying illegal equipment have dropped significantly," Donovan said. "You know, what used to be you know to get a transmitter which might take the size of a room and you got to spend thousands and thousands of dollars getting the antenna up. Now it can be the size of a large trunk or suitcase.”

 

The cost of buying illegal transmitters is a "drop of a bucket," according to Donovan, at only five to 10 thousand dollars. Anyone can buy illegal transmitters from overseas or online.

 

Daniel Roberts, founder and director of Pirate Cat Radio, said it makes a lot of sense to take his station online, create a lot of content and then decide which on-air markets the content fit best in. He echoed Donovan that equipment for pirate radio is easy to come by, as he began broadcasting at age 15.

 

“Pirate Cat radio started in 1996," Roberts said. "I launched it out of my bedroom as a pirate radio station that I just sort of built out from old electronic parts I was able to pull together.”

 

The Austin Case

 

Ajit Pai, the FCC chairman appointed by President Donald Trump, has stopping pirate radio as one of his highest priorities since his term began.

 

One case that became a big news topic for pirate radio was the Austin case. According to an NPR news report, the FCC sued a pirate station in Texas for $15,000 because they've broadcasted without a license since 2013.

 

Yet the operators of the pirate radio station, Texas Liberty Radio, “rejected the demand and accuse the Federal Communications Commission of ‘trying to run a bluff.’"

"It is important to make clear that our pirate radio enforcement efforts — including this one — have nothing to do with the content of pirate radio stations air," Pai said in response. "We act against pirate radio station because they are violating the law by broadcasting on the FM airwaves without a license." (NPR)

OUR WRITERS

OUR WRITERS
DSC04331.jpg

Giulia Villanueva is a junior at Ithaca College majoring in journalism and minoring in international politics

and French. She’s from Paraguay and aims to become an international journalist. She likes to report on global human right issues both through writing and video. She works on ICTV and 92 WICB Radio

Contact:

  • Black Twitter Icon
jeb biggart.jpg

James (Jeb) Biggart is a senior at Roy. H Park School of Communications at Ithaca College. He is currently pursuing a

degree in journalism with a minor in business administration. He works as a full-time writer for 12Up Sports, a media outlet of Minute Media Inc. He hopes to move to New York City and continue his research on the pirate radio scene.

Contact:

22137114_10214223991851247_3394485300826

Becky Mehorter is a junior Spanish and journalism double major at Ithaca College. She is also pursuing a minor

in politics. She has an interest in data journalism. She previously worked as a production and development intern for AMC Studios. In her free time, Becky plays lacrosse for the women's intercollegiate team at Ithaca.

Contact:

©2018 by Pirate Radio. Proudly created with Wix.com

Site designed by Becky Mehorter
bottom of page